Three Jimmy’s Good Time Eatery

Reviews

• Jasmyn K.

  star star star star star_border 24 May 2026

  We visited from out of town during our vacation. We brought our 8lb pomeranian chihuahua mix (from Ohio) so we've been very limited to where we could visit.
  
  The restaurant was on a 15 minute wait, but they allowed us to put our name on the list and wait at our seat on the back patio until they were ready. We appreciated this so we didn't have to wait out front or in the car with our pup.
  
  The drinks and food were great! Service was fast and efficient. The carrot cake was to die for!! I would definitely visit again.
  
  My only complaint is smoking is allowed on the back patio. Where we live smoking is banned within 20 feet of any food-based establishment, as a non-smoker this is something I often take advantage of.
  
  Within the hour we ate, the people sitting next to us smoked 12 cigarettes, back to back. When I drink alcohol, tobacco smoke instantly makes me sick. I certainly do not hold this against the restuarant, because if the law allows - they cannot limit someone's cigarette intake... I will however say it was not the most pleasant/enjoyable experience due to that. I limited myself to one drink and still felt sick upon leaving.
  
  Would love to see a designated smoking area on the patio so those who are limited to seating due to fur friends can still enjoy a smoke-free meal.

• Joshua C.

  star star star star star 13 May 2026

  Went on August 11th 2019..
  Another outstanding experience...
  I had the 16 ounce ribeye...
  This was the best steak I ever had... absolutely delicious...
  Then the gouda Mac and cheese did not disappoint...the cinnamon apples were a treat as well...

• Bryan H.

  star star star star star_border 12 May 2026

  This was a great meal! I had the pot roast with mash potatoes and gravy. The gravy was a little over peppered but I like a lot of pepper so it didn't slow me down.
  
  My with had the Triple Jimmy. It was really good. The meat was all cooked perfectly. The sauces were very good and they don't skimp on the portions.
  
  We also ordered a side of the Gouda mac and cheese. It was awesome! I read some other reviews that said the mac was to hard but ours was served perfectly I'll Al dente.
  
  Shea was our waitress and she did a great job.
  
  My only criticism was with the desserts. I had the pecan pie. It tasted Great but there was literally only 3 bites of it. That's not much for a $6 slice of pie.
  My wife had the carrot cake. She said it was OK but nothing to rave about.
  
  All in all we would definitely go back. It was a good experience with really good food.

• Jessie M.

  star star star star star 8 May 2026

  Great experience! Stopped in for a late lunch with the family. We did not have to wait for a table and our server was very sweet. Our food came rapidly and was exactly as ordered. We ordered wings as our appetizer- blackberry and they were delicious! I ordered the black cow sandwich- nicely smoked beef with my onions and mushrooms. I could have gone for some more caper Mayo - there wasn't enough to really add to the sandwich. Over all a very good meal!

• Katie R.

  star star star star star 8 May 2026

  I had a great experience at Three Jimmy's on a recent trip to Gatlinburg. It's well off of the main strip, which means it's more of a local hangout. Much preferred to the crowds downtown! I decided to sit at the bar since I was dining solo. The bartender was super friendly and very attentive. I had a basic meal - burger and two beers - but it was all delicious. Would definitely go back if I was in the area.